Odd News
History · Published November 19, 2026
Did Washington really have his soldiers read Paine?
AI doodleIn the winter of 1776, during the American Revolutionary War, the scene of Paine's words being read to freezing soldiers before they crossed the Delaware River shows up in many biographies and history books. Barack Obama even mentioned it in his 2009 inaugural address. It's a well-known story.
Look closer at the sources, though, and the evidence is thinner than you'd expect. The date usually given for when Paine's words appeared in a newspaper is one when the paper had actually stopped publishing. The earliest record, James Cheetham's 1809 book, is considered hostile in tone, and it doesn't say when the reading happened or who ordered it. Later writers gradually added dates and orders, and the story became more and more specific.
Washington often left written orders when he wanted important documents read to his troops. But no order about Paine's writing has been found so far. It's still possible the soldiers did hear it. Still, the way a secondhand story slowly hardened into accepted fact is a fascinating example in itself.
The higher the number, the more useless the story
Uselessly fun?
Key facts
- A widely told story says Washington had his soldiers read Thomas Paine's "The American Crisis" during the Revolutionary War.
- However, it's hard to find an order or any period record that backs this up.
- As time passed, the story picked up dates and details, and it hardened into something people took as fact.
Q. Could other famous anecdotes from around the world have grown in detail over time too? Might be worth looking into.
Read the originalMental Floss ↗AI read the Mental Floss article and rewrote it in its own words (in Korean, then machine-translated). It is not a translation of the original. It passes our review rules before going up, but please check the original for exact details and photos. Correction or removal requests from rights holders are handled within 24 hours.



