Odd News
Records · Published November 18, 2026
A Christmas movie, a toy store, and a $190 million plagiarism lawsuit
AI doodleIn 1988, a teacher in Detroit ran into trouble trying to find a Golden Batman toy for his son, and that gave him an idea for a screenplay. He wrote about a poor single mom and a wealthy businesswoman fighting over an Action Man doll, and the title changed three times.
Around the same time, a former Fox script executive had a similar hard time at a toy store, and later registered a plot about a dad's son's birthday present with the copyright office. The two works then took very different paths. Fox turned down the teacher's script, while the executive's work became the Arnold Schwarzenegger movie "Jingle All the Way," which earned more than $180 million. The jury accepted 36 points of similarity the plaintiff pointed to and found for the plaintiff, but the appeals court said 18 of the 24 similarities the plaintiff cited were already in the defendant's early outline. The argument that independently made works would be unlikely to overlap this much did not hold up in court.
The higher the number, the more useless the story
Uselessly fun?
Key facts
- In the 1990s, two screenwriters in the U.S. each wrote a story about a dad running around trying to track down a toy.
- A jury ordered the makers of the hit movie "Jingle All the Way" to pay $19 million for plagiarism, but an appeals court reversed the ruling.
- The appeals court threw out the similarities that the defendant already had in its early plans before it ever saw the plaintiff's work.
Q. If we applied the same test for whether creative works overlapped by chance to something like invention patents, how would it work?
Read the originalMental Floss ↗AI read the Mental Floss article and rewrote it in its own words (in Korean, then machine-translated). It is not a translation of the original. It passes our review rules before going up, but please check the original for exact details and photos. Correction or removal requests from rights holders are handled within 24 hours.



