Odd News
Records · Published November 11, 2026
Kurt Vonnegut's Report Card for His Own Books
ⓘ This story involves death or an accident.
AI doodleIn 1981, Kurt Vonnegut graded his own work from A to D in Palm Sunday, a collection of speeches, essays, and letters. The yardstick wasn't literary history. It was his own work, measured against itself. He gave Cat's Cradle an A+, though he acknowledged that there had been a writer named Shakespeare.
The lowest grade, a D, went to his 1976 novel Slapstick. It's the story of giant, grotesque twins who are geniuses when together and ordinary when apart. The author called it the closest thing to an autobiography he had written, and the twins were modeled on him and his sister Alice. Alice died of cancer in 1958.
The critics were brutal. Greil Marcus, writing in Rolling Stone, called the novel cute, contrived, debasing, and emotionally empty. A few years later, Vonnegut agreed, at least on paper, with some of the harsh reviews. The report card is a rare record of how the author looked back on his own work.
The higher the number, the more useless the story
Uselessly fun?
Key facts
- In 1981, Kurt Vonnegut graded his own work from A to D in Palm Sunday, a collage of autobiographical writing.
- Slapstick got a D. Its twin protagonists were modeled on the author and his sister.
- Critics savaged the book, and Vonnegut reportedly came to agree with some of their criticism later on.
Q. If you set your own rules for grading creative work, what would your standard be?
Read the originalMental Floss ↗AI read the Mental Floss article and rewrote it in its own words (in Korean, then machine-translated). It is not a translation of the original. It passes our review rules before going up, but please check the original for exact details and photos. Correction or removal requests from rights holders are handled within 24 hours.



