Odd Memes
The "Glenn Beck raped and murdered a girl in 1990" domain case, the full story
A joke becomes a meme, and the meme ends up in court.
AI doodleWhat does this meme mean?
- Meaning
- How it's used
AMr. Beck, want to prove you didn't do that in 1990?
BAsking someone to prove a negative is kind of a nonsense demand, isn't it?
- When it took off
- On September 1, 2009, Isaac Eiland-Hall launched a satire site, and after Beck's side filed a domain dispute, it went all the way to a WIPO ruling.
Where it came from
The seed of this story was Bob Saget's roast on Comedy Central in 2008. Gilbert Gottfried joked, "Please, everybody, don't believe the rumor that Saget raped and killed a girl in 1990!" The rumor was completely made up, and the more he kept going, the more absurd it got, and the audience burst out laughing.
In late August 2009, someone on the American forum Fark pinned that joke on Glenn Beck, poking fun at his habit of telling opponents to "prove it isn't true." Commenters wrote things like "Mr. Beck, please prove you didn't do that," and the meme spread across social media, YouTube, and Twitter.
Seeing this, a guy named Eiland-Hall created a site on September 1. The page drew more than 120,000 views in its first 24 hours, so it clearly caught attention. Beck's side didn't just sit back. They asked for the domain to be taken down and filed a dispute with WIPO, citing trademark infringement and bad-faith registration. On October 29, 2009, WIPO rejected Beck's claims, ruling that this was political commentary through parody.
Many people noted that the dispute produced a Streisand effect, where trying to suppress the site only made it more famous. It was a funny meme that ended up in court, and it's still pretty entertaining to look back on.



