Odd Tales
News taleThe absurd 1850 experiment by a French inventor who wanted to send messages with snails
In Paris in 1850, a device appeared that claimed to enable instant communication anywhere in the world using two snails.
AI translation
More than 170 years ago, a French inventor announced an invention that was supposed to turn the world upside down. He claimed you could send and receive messages instantly over any distance, with no wires or cables at all. And this was 45 years before Marconi demonstrated wireless telegraphy. But the core of this technology is even crazier: it supposedly relied on a mysterious "biological connection" between two snails.
The inventor's name was Jacques Toussaint Benoit. He believed that snails that had mated once were left with an invisible "sympathetic connection," so they could send signals to each other no matter how far apart they were. Back then, the telegraph was just starting to change the world in Europe, and people were hungry for faster, cheaper ways to send news. So you can see why a pitch like this would make people's ears perk up.
And here's another twist. Benoit approached Triat, the manager of a gymnasium in Paris, and managed to win him over. When Triat asked what equipment he'd need, Benoit's answer was unbelievable: "Just two or three pieces of wood." Taking him at his word, Triat gave him a carpentry workshop, provided him a place to live, and even paid his living expenses every month. But it kept taking more and more wood, the carpenter's labor costs kept piling up, and a whole year later there was still nothing to show for it. Only when Triat cut off the money did Benoit finally declare, "It's done."
The finished product was something else. Two big wooden frames, a little over 3 meters long, were set up at opposite ends of a room, and each one had 24 zinc bowls arranged in a circle in alphabetical order. The bottom of each bowl was lined with cloth soaked in copper sulfate solution, and a snail was glued on top. Apparently the snails would stretch out their antennae trying to escape, and when they touched the copper sulfate, they'd pull right back into their shells. Calling that a "signaling device"? It's the kind of thing that's funny and kind of sad at the same time.
The inventor who said distance didn't matter ended up setting the two machines up facing each other in the same room, because the room was too small. Triat suggested at least putting a partition between them, but Benoit refused, saying it was technically impossible. Then, on demonstration day, in front of journalist Jules Allix, when "gymnase" (gymnasium) was sent, Benoit received "gymoate," and when Triat sent "lumière divine" (divine light), what came through was "lumhere divine." If it was that bad within a single room, of course people got suspicious. On top of that, there are signs that Benoit kept walking back and forth between the two machines, so he could have just looked at the letters and sent them along himself.
But Allix, the journalist, was actually moved by it all, and on October 27, 1850, he ran a glowing article in the newspaper La Presse. Triat said this proved nothing and demanded a new demonstration under these conditions: a partition up, the machines in separate rooms, and Benoit not allowed anywhere near the equipment. He offered to pay 1,000 francs a day if it worked. Even the newspaper's owner, Émile de Girardin, got in on it, throwing in another 1,000 francs a day, and there was even talk of holding a public demonstration in a winter garden if it succeeded.
So how did it turn out? On the agreed day, Benoit just vanished. He was later spotted wandering the streets of Paris looking like a beggar, and he died in 1852. And so the "Pasilalinic-Sympathetic Compass" became a textbook example of a ridiculous invention that literally fell apart the moment it was put to the test.
But that's not the end of it. The person who shared the original story left a thought: maybe the "Den Den Mushi" (transponder snails) from the world of One Piece were inspired by this story. The idea of communicating through snails is exactly the same, right? Whether that's actually true hasn't been confirmed, but it's pretty fun to imagine that a ridiculous experiment from 1850s Paris came back to life more than 100 years later as tech in an anime.