Odd News
People & culture · Published November 14, 2026
Why the people who don't cry in church cry at the theater
AI doodleThe famous English actor David Garrick was once challenged by a clergyman. Churchgoers, the clergyman pointed out, almost never shed a tear, yet the very same people cry easily when they sit in a theater and watch a made-up sad story.
Garrick's answer was short. The theater repeats fiction as if it were true, while the church repeats truth as if it were fiction. In other words, even a truth you have heard a hundred times can lose its punch once it becomes routine.
The exchange is recorded in a joke collection published in 1816. It is a light joke comparing religion and drama, but it makes a real point: the same story can hit with very different weight depending on where and how it is told.
The higher the number, the more useless the story
Uselessly fun?
Key facts
- A clergyman once put a question to David Garrick, the 18th-century English actor.
- His point was that churchgoers rarely cry, yet the same people cry easily at the theater.
- Garrick replied that theater repeats fiction as if it were truth, while church repeats truth as if it were fiction.
Q. Pick one thing that has lost its impact because it became familiar. How would you tell it fresh again?
Read the originalFutility Closet ↗AI read the Futility Closet article and rewrote it in its own words (in Korean, then machine-translated). It is not a translation of the original. It passes our review rules before going up, but please check the original for exact details and photos. Correction or removal requests from rights holders are handled within 24 hours.



